Treadstone Associates
Article · Marketing & business development

Can AI write SEO content for my firm?

Yes, with two conditions that have nothing to do with writing quality. The page has to add something a reader could not get elsewhere, and every claim on it has to be one you can prove.

Treadstone Associates · Updated 2026

Key takeaways

  • • Google’s policy is not about authorship. Google’s spam policies for Google Web Search define scaled content abuse as generating many pages primarily to manipulate rankings rather than to help users, “no matter how it’s created”.
  • • The same policies define site reputation abuse — third-party content published on a host site mainly because of that host’s established ranking signals.
  • • Every claim on the page is a representation. section 74.01 of the Competition Act puts the proof of an adequate and proper test on whoever makes a performance claim, and section 74.011 reaches a false or misleading representation in a locator.
  • • If you are licensed, your regulator’s marketing rule sits on top. Rule 4.2-1 of the Law Society of Ontario’s Rules of Professional Conduct permits marketing only if it is demonstrably true, accurate and verifiable.

The short answer

AI can write publishable content for a professional firm, and Google’s published policy does not say otherwise. What it prohibits is scale without value. The practical test is whether each page would still be worth publishing if search did not exist — whether it answers a question a client actually asks, in a way that reflects what your firm knows.

For a regulated practice a second test applies and it is stricter: the page is marketing, and your regulator has a rule about marketing. That rule usually reaches accuracy and verifiability, which is precisely where generated copy is weakest.

What the policy actually says

Google’s spam policies for Google Web Search define scaled content abuse as “when many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users”, typically focused on creating large amounts of unoriginal content that provides little to no value, “no matter how it’s created”. The listed examples include using generative AI tools to generate many pages without adding value for users, stitching or combining content from different web pages without adding value, and creating many pages whose content makes little sense to a reader but contains search keywords.

Two things follow. The mechanism is irrelevant — a hundred thin pages written by people is the same violation. And “adding value” is doing the work in that sentence, which for a professional firm means the specific thing you have that a general article does not: the Canadian rule, the provincial variation, the recurring client problem, the number you can source.

The same document defines site reputation abuse, where third-party content is published on a host site mainly because of the host’s already-established ranking signals. Firms that let an agency publish syndicated material under the firm’s name should read that section carefully.

The professional-firm version of adding value

  • • Name the jurisdiction. Canadian professional questions almost always have a provincial answer. A page that says “the rules require” without naming the regulator is the generic content the policy is aimed at.
  • • Cite something a reader can open. A link to the statute, the regulator’s guidance or the published dataset is both the value and the proof. A model will happily cite from memory; every link has to be opened before it is published.
  • • Answer the question in the first two sentences. If the answer only arrives in paragraph nine, the page was written for a word count.
  • • Publish under a person. A named professional who reviewed it is the difference between a firm’s content and content that happens to be on a firm’s site.

The regulator’s marketing rule

For an Ontario lawyer, rule 4.2-1 permits marketing of legal services only if it is demonstrably true, accurate and verifiable; is neither misleading, confusing nor deceptive nor likely to mislead, confuse or deceive; and is in the best interests of the public and consistent with a high standard of professionalism. Rule 4.3-1 separately prohibits advertising that the lawyer is a specialist in a field unless certified by the Law Society — a rule that a generated page describing the firm as “specialists in” something will breach without anyone intending it.

CPAs, engineers and insurance brokers work under their own regulator’s version. The common shape is the same: verifiable, not misleading, no implied credential you do not hold. Read yours before the content calendar is signed off, not after.

Claims and the Competition Act

A firm website promotes a business interest, so section 74.01 of the Competition Act applies. Paragraph (1)(a) reaches a representation to the public that is false or misleading in a material respect. Paragraph (1)(b) reaches a statement, warranty or guarantee of performance or efficacy not based on an adequate and proper test, and states that the proof of that test lies on the person making the representation. section 74.011 reaches a false or misleading representation in a locator, which is worth knowing if page titles and URLs are being generated at scale.

This is the concrete reason to run a claims register on generated content. A model produces “the leading firm for”, “guaranteed within 48 hours” and confident comparative statements as a matter of style. Each of those needs a source or it comes out. Treadstone Law’s notes on misleading advertising and on comparative advertising cover the ground.

A pipeline that survives review

  • • Source before draft. Give the model your own material — a guide, a memo, a submission — and ask it to reduce that. A model writing from nothing invents; a model compressing a document you stand behind mostly does not.
  • • Open every link. Citations produced from memory are the single most common defect. If it will not open, it does not go in.
  • • Claims register. Numbers, comparisons and superlatives listed with sources before drafting.
  • • One named reviewer per page, recorded. That record is your evidence of review if the regulator asks.
  • • Publish fewer, better. The policy targets volume without value; the defence is not volume with a disclaimer.

Worked example (illustrative)

A mid-sized Ontario firm is offered a programme of 200 search-optimised articles at a low per-page price. The sample reads fluently and says nothing that could not be said about any firm in any country.

The firm runs a smaller version instead. It lists the thirty questions clients actually ask, in the words clients use. For each, a partner records five minutes of answer; a model turns that into a draft; the drafter opens every citation and cuts anything the partner did not say. Three claims are removed at the register step and one page is dropped entirely because the honest answer was “it depends on your contract” and the page could not improve on that. Each published page names the partner who reviewed it.

Thirty pages ship over a quarter rather than two hundred in a month. Each names the province, cites something openable, and answers in the first two sentences.

Measure enquiries that reference a specific page, questions the intake team no longer has to answer from scratch, and pages a partner is willing to send to a client. Not word count, and not published volume.

Where this sits in the firm

This page is written for a firm that delivers work to a book of clients. If the question is really about the front desk — intake, scheduling, recall and reminders — that lives on the professional practice owners page. If it is about your own month-end, reconciliation and payables rather than what you deliver to clients, that is accounting automation, or bookkeeping automation for coding and receipt capture. The tooling overlaps; the risk almost never does.

Questions we get asked

Will Google penalise us for using AI?
Not for authorship. Google’s spam policies for Google Web Search target the pattern — many pages generated primarily to manipulate rankings and not to help users, however they were created. The exposure comes from scale without value, not from the tool.

Do we have to disclose that a page was AI-drafted?
No general Canadian rule requires it for ordinary marketing content. Naming the professional who reviewed the page does more for a reader’s trust than a disclaimer, and it is also what your regulator’s accuracy rule effectively presumes.

Can we let an agency publish under our name?
You can, and you remain responsible for it under your regulator’s marketing rule and under section 74.01 of the Competition Act. Read the site reputation abuse section of Google’s spam policies for Google Web Search as well before agreeing to syndicated material.

Publish fewer pages that a partner will stand behind.

A 30-minute call is enough to tell you whether AI pays for itself here.