Treadstone Associates
Article · Pricing

Should I charge fixed fees or hourly?

The honest test is not which model you prefer. It is how wide the spread of actual effort is on work of that shape — and your closed jobs already know.

Treadstone Associates · Updated 2026

Key takeaways

  • • Fix the fee where variance is low and you control the inputs. Bill hourly where scope depends on a third party.
  • • The evidence is your own closed engagements: the distribution of effort, not the average.
  • • Whichever model you choose, a regulated fee must still be fair, reasonable and disclosed in a timely fashion.
  • • A headline price that is not attainable because of obligatory add-on charges is a misleading representation under the Competition Act.

The short answer

Fix the fee where the work is predictable enough that your own history can price it, and bill hourly where the amount of work depends on someone else’s behaviour — an opposing party, a regulator, a client who supplies records in fragments. AI’s contribution is the history: it can group closed engagements by shape rather than by the label on the invoice, and show you the distribution of actual effort within each group. The average is not the useful number. The spread is.

This is a portfolio decision about which model suits which kind of work, not the pricing of one engagement in front of you. Those are different jobs and they use different evidence.

The test is variance, not preference

Take a job type you run often. Pull every closed instance from the last two or three years and plot the effort actually recorded. If the middle eighty per cent sits in a narrow band and the tail is short, that work can carry a fixed fee, because you can price the band and absorb the tail. If the tail is long — a handful of jobs at three or four times the median — a fixed fee transfers a risk you cannot price to a firm that cannot carry it.

The second question is who causes the tail. If long jobs are long because of your own staffing or scope control, fixing the fee is a healthy discipline that forces you to solve it. If they are long because a third party behaves unpredictably, fixing the fee is a bet on a coin you do not toss.

What AI does here

  • • Grouping. Cluster closed engagements by what the work actually involved, read from the narratives and deliverables, instead of by the service code someone picked at set-up.
  • • Distribution. Produce the spread of effort per group, with the long jobs identified so a partner can read what happened on each.
  • • Attribution. Propose, from the file record, whether each long job ran long because of internal or external causes — and quote the sentences it relied on.
  • • Scenario drafting. Write the fee-basis paragraph for the engagement letter under each model, so the choice is made against real wording rather than an abstraction.

What it does not do is decide. A pricing model determines which clients you can serve and which you cannot, and that is an owner’s decision made with the numbers in front of them.

What the professional rules add

For lawyers in Ontario, the model is largely a business choice but the fee is not. Rule 3.6-1 of the Rules of Professional Conduct provides that a lawyer shall not charge or accept any amount for a fee or a disbursement unless it is fair and reasonable and has been disclosed in a timely fashion, and its commentary lists the factors that bear on that — among them the time and effort required and spent, the difficulty of the matter, the results obtained, and any estimate or range of fees the lawyer gave. Rule 3.6-3 requires the statement of account to detail fees and disbursements clearly and separately, which applies to a fixed fee as much as to an hourly one.

Contingency arrangements are a third model with their own limits. Rule 3.6-2 permits a lawyer to enter a contingency fee agreement in accordance with the Solicitors Act and its regulations, except in family law, Criminal Code matters, or any other criminal or quasi-criminal matter. Rule 3.6-2.1 adds disclosure requirements, including providing the Law Society’s consumer guide and a reasonable opportunity to consider it before the agreement is entered into, and requirements for what the bill must show. Treadstone Law’s comparison of hourly and flat-fee litigation billing and its article on contingency fees set out how the two models feel from the client’s side, which is worth reading before you redesign your own.

Other professions run the same idea through different bodies — your provincial CPA body, Professional Engineers Ontario and its provincial counterparts, or the insurance regulator in your province. Name yours and read its rule; do not reason from a law society rule if you are not a lawyer.

Advertising the number

A fixed fee is a public price, and public prices are regulated. Section 74.01 of the Competition Act makes it reviewable conduct to make a representation to the public that is false or misleading in a material respect for the purpose of promoting a product or a business interest. Subsection 74.01(1.1) states for greater certainty that representing a price that is not attainable because of fixed obligatory charges or fees is a false or misleading representation, unless those charges are imposed by or under an Act of Parliament or a provincial legislature.

So the ‘$1,500 flat fee’ that always becomes $1,500 plus a mandatory file-opening charge is the textbook version of the problem, and the fix is to publish the number the client will actually pay. Paragraph 74.01(1)(c) adds a related trap for anyone tempted to promise a fixed price with an open-ended promise attached: a purported promise to repeat or continue a service until it achieves a specified result is caught where there is no reasonable prospect it will be carried out. The Competition Bureau administers this.

Worked example (illustrative)

A five-person consultancy prices everything hourly and loses two competitive proposals in a quarter to firms quoting a number. Rather than guess, it clusters three years of closed engagements and finds two distinct populations inside what it had been calling one service: a discovery-and-report engagement with a tight effort band, and a discovery-report-and-implementation-support engagement with a long tail driven entirely by how quickly the client’s own staff respond.

The firm fixes the first and keeps the second hourly, with a written assumption in the engagement letter about client response times and a stated consequence if they are not met. The published price for the fixed product includes everything obligatory, because the alternative is a representation of a price nobody can actually obtain.

The measures to keep are the spread of effort within the fixed product after twelve months, and the proportion of hourly engagements where the response-time assumption was invoked. If the first widens, the product needs re-scoping; if the second is never invoked, the assumption is decoration.

Questions we get asked

Can we fix the fee and keep a get-out?
You can state assumptions and a mechanism for varying the fee if they fail — that is normal and honest. What does not work is a ‘fixed’ fee with an unstated escape, which is the arrangement that generates complaints.

Does fixed pricing hurt realisation?
It moves the risk. Realisation on a fixed fee is decided when you set the price and when you control scope, not when you bill. Firms that fix fees without tightening scope control get the worst of both.

Is value-based pricing a third option?
In substance it is a fixed fee justified differently, and the same rules apply: fair, reasonable, disclosed in time, and advertised at a price the client can actually obtain.

See where AI pays off first in your firm.

A 30-minute call is enough to tell you whether AI pays for itself here.