The client
A household in Cobourg broke a 5-year fixed mortgage two years before its own term ended, moving a $340,000 balance to a new lender at a materially better rate.
Mortgage balance
$340,000
2 years remaining on a 5-year term
Discounted contract rate
5.29%
Actually advanced and written on the mortgage commitment
Lender's original posted rate
6.99%
What the borrower would have paid without any discount -- never actually charged
Current comparison rate
4.09%
The lender's own rate for a term matching the 2 years remaining
The problem
An interest-rate-differential penalty compares two rates: the rate the mortgage was actually written at, and the lender's current rate for a term matching what is left to run. The discharge statement priced the first side of that comparison off the lender's original posted rate -- 6.99% -- rather than the 5.29% discounted rate actually on the contract.
What the discharge statement got backwards
- ▸The mortgage's own commitment letter shows a discounted 5.29% rate, advanced and paid for the mortgage's entire life
- ▸The lender's posted rate for that same original term, at the same time, was 6.99% -- a rate this borrower never paid for a single day
- ▸The discharge statement's IRD calculation used 6.99% as the 'old' rate, not the 5.29% the mortgage actually carried
Nobody disputed the current 4.09% comparison rate, or the arithmetic once a rate went in on each side. The rate that went in on the 'old' side was simply the wrong one.
The numbers
Running the identical IRD formula with the correct discounted rate on one side, instead of the posted rate, is the entire difference between these two figures.
| Two penalties, one mortgage | Amount |
|---|---|
| Differential using the posted rate (6.99% - 4.09%) | 2.90 points |
| Differential using the actual contract rate (5.29% - 4.09%) | 1.20 points |
| Penalty on the posted-rate differential | $19,728 |
| Penalty on the correct, contract-rate differential | $8,160 |
| Penalty comparison | On the posted rate | On the actual contract rate |
|---|---|---|
| Rate differential | 2.90 points | 1.20 points |
| Monthly interest on that differential | $822 | $340 |
| Penalty over the 24 months remaining | $19,728 / $8,160 |
The $11,568 gap is not a dispute about how an interest-rate-differential penalty works -- both figures use the identical formula, the identical $340,000 balance and the identical 24 months remaining. The only input that changed was which rate stood in for the mortgage the borrower actually had.
The solution
A mortgage agent licensed under Ontario's Mortgage Brokerages, Lenders and Administrators Act treated the discharge statement's rate as a claim to verify, not a number to accept.
First, pulled the original commitment letter. It showed the 5.29% discounted rate and confirmed the mortgage had never carried the 6.99% posted rate for any part of its term.
Second, went back to the lender's discharge desk with that document, asking for the interest-rate-differential to be recalculated using 5.29% as the contract-rate side of the comparison, not 6.99%.
Third, confirmed the corrected $8,160 figure independently before letting the new lender's solicitor rely on it to size the switch.
The outcome
The corrected $8,160 penalty, not $19,728, funded the switch to a new 4.65% five-year fixed mortgage, with the balance and remaining amortization unchanged.
Because this is an uninsured switch, CMHC's ratio maximums do not apply directly; the 37.8% total-debt-service figure is informational, confirming the file had ample room either way.
What to take from this file
- 01An interest-rate-differential penalty's 'old rate' side should be the discounted rate actually on the contract, not the posted rate the lender would have charged without a discount. Confirm which one a discharge statement actually used before accepting its total.
- 02The original commitment letter is the primary source for the contract rate. A discharge statement's own stated rate is a claim, not a document.
- 03Comparing against a posted rate instead of the discounted rate actually advanced is a documented practice at some lenders, not a universal formula. Ask which one applies before assuming a penalty figure is correct.
- 04An $11,568 gap can hide inside an otherwise unremarkable switch. A file with no other complications is exactly where a rate substitution like this is easiest to miss.
Sources
Every regulatory figure in this file traces to one of these primary sources. Client details and anything that varies by lender are illustrative, as flagged below.
- ▸OSFI — Minimum qualifying rate for uninsured mortgages — the minimum qualifying rate — greater of contract rate + 2% or 5.25%.
- ▸Provincial/territorial mortgage-broker legislation fetched directly (bclaws.gov.bc.ca, legisquebec.gouv.qc.ca, fcaa.gov.sk.ca, web2.gov.mb.ca, nslegislature.ca, assembly.nl.ca) plus FCNB's own site for NB and CanLII's index for PE — see notes for per-province method — provincial mortgage regulators and licence titles.
Illustrative in this file — lender-specific, not rules:
- ▸5.29% / 6.99% / 4.09% / 4.65% rates — rates move daily and vary by lender; none is a quote.
- ▸the practice of comparing against an original posted rate rather than the discounted contract rate — each lender publishes its own IRD methodology; this reflects one documented practice, not a universal formula or a rule.
Authority & provenance
How this case file was built
We publish the origin, the verification method and the reviewer for every case file, so you can judge how far to trust it before you rely on it with a client.
Where it comes from
Derived from files handled by Treadstone’s fulfillment desk and from scenarios contributed by partner brokerages. Names, employers, exact amounts and dates are changed so no client or file is identifiable.
Provenance: Composite — a pattern seen repeatedly on fulfilled files, not a single transaction.
What is verified
Every regulatory figure traces to a primary source listed above and was checked against it on the date shown. The arithmetic is recomputed by machine on every rebuild.
Anything that varies by lender is labelled illustrative rather than stated as a rule.
Who reviewed it
Reviewed for Canadian regulatory accuracy before publication, and re-checked whenever a cited rule changes.
Reviewed by: Nicholas Parson, Treadstone Associates — reviews every case file before publication.
This case file is professional reference material for licensed mortgage professionals. It is not advice to a borrower, and it is not a lender commitment. Insurer rules, qualifying rates and provincial taxes change — confirm the current position with the insurer, regulator or lender before you rely on any figure here in a live file.