Treadstone Associates
Case File № 171 · Rental & Investment

Averaging a ski season

the Collingwood rental income two lenders read differently

A Collingwood rental leased at a premium winter rate and a lower off-season rate pushed TDS to 54.0% when one lender refused to average it. A lender that credits a 12-month average, offset at 80%, brought the same file to 37.3%.

OntarioUninsured · 20% downFiled August 7, 20266 min read
54.0%

TDS under Bank A, which won’t average the seasonal leases — declined

37.3%

TDS under Lender B, which averages the leases and offsets 80% of the result

$2,600/mo

the 12-month averaged rental income — only one lender would use it

Anonymized illustration. The borrowers, dollar figures, and rates in this file are an illustrative composite — no real client is identifiable, and any rate shown is illustrative, not a quote. The rules are real: every regulatory figure is cited to its source in the Sources section, and the math computes exactly as shown.

№ 01

The client

A couple buying a rental property in the Collingwood market had already done the part most investors skip: they had two signed leases in hand before they ever applied for financing. A ski-season tenant had the unit for the winter peak at a premium rate; a second tenant covered the rest of the year at a lower, off-season rate. Both leases were real and both were signed — the disagreement that nearly killed the file was entirely about how a lender is supposed to read seasonal income at all, in a market where Canadian rental vacancy stays tight enough that a ski-town unit rarely sits empty.

Borrowers

Couple, both salaried

$150,000/year combined

Own housing

$2,900/month

Their existing principal-residence carrying cost

Purchase

$610,000 rental, Collingwood

20% down ($122,000); uninsured investment property

Winter lease

$3,900/month, 4 months

Dec-Mar, signed

Off-season lease

$1,950/month, 8 months

Apr-Nov, signed

First lender tried

Bank A: 0% of either lease counted

Policy varies by lender on non-standard seasonal income

The subject property's own carrying costs, before any rent is credited:

Subject property (qualifying)Monthly
P&I at the qualifying rate (mortgage $488,000 at 6.89%)$3,385
Property tax$310
Heat (lender-standard estimate)$150
Total qualifying carrying cost$3,845
№ 02

The problem

Bank A's underwriting desk requires a single, continuous 12-month lease at one rate before any rental income counts toward qualifying at all. Two leases at two different rates, on the same unit, in the same year, did not fit that template — so the file was read as if the property earned nothing, with the full $3,845 in carrying costs landing as a pure liability.

The zero-credit arithmetic

  • ▸Liabilities: $2,900 own housing + $3,845 subject carrying cost = $6,745/mo
  • ▸TDS: $6,745 ÷ $12,500 income = 54.0% — declined outright

Nothing about the leases themselves was in question. The winter tenant's agreement and the off-season tenant's agreement were both signed, both at defensible market rates for their respective seasons, and both already in the file. What Bank A's policy could not accommodate was the shape of the income — two rates in one year — not its reality.

№ 03

The numbers

At 20% down this is a conventional, uninsured purchase, so there is no default-insurance premium to add — but the full minimum qualifying rate still applies to the debt-service math.

Structuring the uninsured purchaseAmount
Purchase price$610,000
Down payment (20%)−$122,000
Mortgage$488,000
Rate & paymentsFigure
Contract rate — 5-year fixed (illustrative, not a quote)4.89%
Minimum qualifying rate — greater of contract + 2% and 5.25%6.89%
Monthly P&I at the qualifying rate — the ratios run on this$3,385
Monthly P&I at the contract rate — what would actually be paid$2,808

Turning two leases into one 12-month average

The convention Lender B publishes for seasonal income is straightforward: gross up each lease to its annual contribution, add the two together, and divide by twelve.

Averaging the seasonal leasesFigure
Winter lease: $3,900 × 4 months$15,600
Off-season lease: $1,950 × 8 months$15,600
Annual total$31,200
12-month average$2,600/mo

Bank A vs. Lender B, side by side

The seasonal-income treatment that decides this file, and the 80% rental offset Lender B applies to the averaged figure, are both illustrative of policies that vary lender to lender.

TDS lineBank ALender B
Own housing$2,900$2,900
Subject carrying cost (full)$3,845—
Averaged rent credited$0$2,600 × 80% = $2,080
Subject net liability$3,845$3,845 − $2,080 = $1,765
TDS54.0%  ✗37.3%  ✓
№ 04

The solution

An FSRA-licensed Ontario mortgage agent treated the decline as a data point about Bank A's documentation policy, not a verdict on the file. Every seasonal-rental client hears the same thing at the first bank; the fix is knowing which lenders on the shelf actually have a published averaging convention for two-rate leases.

The file moved to Lender B, whose underwriting guidelines explicitly cover a multi-rate seasonal lease: gross up each period to its annual value, average across twelve months, then apply the same 80% offset the lender uses on any other rental file. Nothing about the leases changed — only which lender's policy got to read them.

✓Both signed seasonal leases, with the winter and off-season rates and periods clearly dated
✓A short cover letter explaining the seasonal rental structure common to the Collingwood market
✓Two years of NOAs for both borrowers
✓90-day history of the $122,000 down payment
✓Purchase agreement and MLS listing
✓Letters of employment confirming salary and tenure for both borrowers

With TDS clearing at 37.3%, there was real margin for underwriting to ask questions without the file falling back over the line. That margin mattered more than the headline swing: a lender new to reading two-rate seasonal leases can still ask for clarification mid-file, and a thin pass leaves no room to answer those questions without the numbers moving against the client.

№ 05

The outcome & the closing math

Approved and funded as an uninsured purchase at 20% down. The last piece of broker work was the cash the closing actually needs, beyond the down payment itself:

Cash due at closing (beyond the down payment)Amount
Ontario land transfer tax on $610,000 — 0.5% / 1.0% / 1.5% / 2.0% marginal brackets$8,675
Legal fees & adjustmentsvaries

Because this is a conventional, uninsured purchase, there is no default-insurance premium and no premium tax — the land transfer tax is the one hard number to budget for beyond legal fees.

№ 06

What to take from this file

  • 01A multi-rate seasonal lease is not the same underwriting event as a single-rate lease, even when both are fully documented. Know which lenders on your shelf actually have a published averaging convention before you submit.
  • 02Averaging is arithmetic, not advocacy. Gross up each season to its annual contribution, add, and divide by twelve — the same method every time, so the number survives a second look.
  • 03A decline over documentation policy is not a decline on the borrower. The leases here never changed; the lender did.
  • 04The qualifying-rate payment, not the contract-rate payment, is what the ratios see. This file qualifies at 6.89% and would actually pay at 4.89%.
  • 05Uninsured does not mean untaxed at closing. Land transfer tax is still cash due on top of the down payment, even with no default-insurance premium in the picture.

Sources

Every regulatory figure in this file traces to one of these primary sources. Client details and anything that varies by lender are illustrative, as flagged below.

Illustrative in this file — lender-specific, not rules:

  • ▸4.89% contract rate — rates move daily; not a quote.
  • ▸Bank A's refusal to average seasonal lease income — documentation policy varies by lender.
  • ▸80% rental offset — each lender publishes its own treatment.

Authority & provenance

How this case file was built

We publish the origin, the verification method and the reviewer for every case file, so you can judge how far to trust it before you rely on it with a client.

Where it comes from

Derived from files handled by Treadstone’s fulfillment desk and from scenarios contributed by partner brokerages. Names, employers, exact amounts and dates are changed so no client or file is identifiable.

Provenance: Composite — a pattern seen repeatedly on fulfilled files, not a single transaction.

What is verified

Every regulatory figure traces to a primary source listed above and was checked against it on the date shown. The arithmetic is recomputed by machine on every rebuild.

Anything that varies by lender is labelled illustrative rather than stated as a rule.

Who reviewed it

Reviewed for Canadian regulatory accuracy before publication, and re-checked whenever a cited rule changes.

Reviewed by: Nicholas Parson, Treadstone Associates — reviews every case file before publication.

First published 7 August 2026Rules last verified 7 August 2026Next scheduled review 7 February 2027

This case file is professional reference material for licensed mortgage professionals. It is not advice to a borrower, and it is not a lender commitment. Insurer rules, qualifying rates and provincial taxes change — confirm the current position with the insurer, regulator or lender before you rely on any figure here in a live file.

Treadstone fulfillment

Files like this are daily work for our desk.

Document collection, ratio math under multiple treatments, lender placement notes, and submission-ready packaging — for Canadian mortgage brokers who would rather be in front of clients.